As the Kansas City Royals gear up for their ambitious 162-game journey to reclaim postseason glory in 2026, there’s a looming specter that could complicate their path: former Royals players now suiting up for their American League Central rivals. With the division shaping up to be more competitive than ever, these familiar faces could become unexpected hurdles for KC. But here’s where it gets intriguing—how will these ex-Royals fare against their former team? Let’s dive into the details and explore the potential storylines that could define this season.
The Royals kick off their season in Atlanta late next month, facing the Braves three times before returning home to host the Minnesota Twins. This marks the beginning of their 52-game gauntlet against AL Central opponents—13 games each against the Twins, White Sox, Guardians, and Tigers. With every team in the division poised for improvement, the Central race promises to be a nail-biter. And this is the part most people miss: the presence of former Royals in rival camps adds an extra layer of drama to the mix.
White Sox — Andrew Benintendi: The Impact Bat That Got Away
Five years ago, the Royals acquired Andrew Benintendi in a mid-February trade, sparking hope among fans that the team could land a game-changing hitter. After taking over left field following Alex Gordon’s retirement, Benintendi thrived, winning a Gold Glove and slashing .294/.351/.424 with 20 homers and 112 RBI in 227 games. Despite his 2022 trade to the Yankees, Benintendi’s career numbers against the Royals (.291/.354/.429) suggest he could be a thorn in their side this season. Now in the second-to-last year of his $75 million deal with the White Sox, he’s a player to watch—but will his past success against KC continue?
Guardians — Carlos Hernández: The Reliever with a Point to Prove
Carlos Hernández spent five seasons with the Royals, posting a 7-19 record and a 4.95 ERA before bouncing between the Phillies, Tigers, and Guardians in 2025. His 6.23 ERA last season raises questions, but Cleveland’s decision to bring him back on a minor league deal hints at untapped potential. If Hernández regains the form that delivered a 3.68 ERA in 2021, he could become a wildcard in the Guardians’ bullpen. Will he turn the tables on his former team?
Twins — Liam Hendriks and Dan Altavilla: The Comeback Stories
Liam Hendriks, a three-time All-Star, had a brief and forgettable stint with the Royals in 2014 but later dominated with the A’s and White Sox. However, health battles, including cancer and Tommy John surgery, have derailed his career in recent years. Now back with the Twins, the 37-year-old’s return to form is uncertain. Meanwhile, Dan Altavilla, another former Royal, posted a solid 2.48 ERA with the White Sox last season but carries a career 4.00 ERA. Will either reliever make an impact against KC, or will their past struggles resurface?
Tigers — Burch Smith: The Long Shot
Burch Smith’s lone season with the Royals in 2018 was underwhelming, with a 6.92 ERA and just six wins. Since then, he’s journeyed through multiple teams, including stints in Japan and Korea, and now finds himself as a non-roster invitee in Detroit’s camp. While the Tigers pose a significant threat to KC’s division title hopes, Smith’s chances of making the roster—and facing the Royals—are slim. But in baseball, stranger things have happened.
The Bigger Picture: A Division on the Rise
The AL Central’s resurgence in 2026 isn’t just about former Royals—it’s about every team stepping up their game. But the presence of these ex-players adds a layer of intrigue and personal stakes to the season. Will they haunt their former club, or will the Royals rise above the challenge?
Controversial Question: Are Former Players More Motivated Against Their Ex-Teams?
Here’s a thought-provoking question for you: Do players like Benintendi, Hernández, or Hendriks have an extra chip on their shoulder when facing their former teams? Or is it all just part of the game? Share your thoughts in the comments—we’d love to hear your take on this age-old baseball debate!
